Modern methods of increasing transparency and quality of the state apparatus formation process

The formation of a professional state apparatus is one of the main tasksset by our authorities. According to the previous experience, reforming the selection process at civil service without proper transparency cannot ensure objective and quality recruitment. The issue of finding and hiring candidates with appropriate competencies and high motivation, as well as increasing the motivation of current employees is of particular relevance today. The main purpose of the work is to develop proposals to improve the transparency and quality of the personnel selection process in the civil service on the basis of a study of the existing system. According to the authors’ predictions, increasing the role of the institute of observers and the use of coaching technologies in the selection process will help to improve the quality and transparency of personnel selection. The authors examine problematic issues in the formation of the state apparatus, focusing on its transparency. In the course of the study, the authors interviewed both the experts who form public service policies and the public servants involved in their implementation. At the same time, an analysis of normative legal acts was conducted. Based on the results of the work, recommendations for improving the transparency of the selection to the civil service were developed, and a mechanism for identifying and selecting motivated employees through the use of modern technologies was considered.

1. Memleket basşysy Qasym-Jomart Toqaevtyñ Qazaqstan halqyna Joldauy. URL: https://www.akorda.kz/kz/memleket-basshysy-kasym-zhomart-tokaevtyn-kazakstan-halkyna-zholdauy-181416 (ötınış be rıl gen kün: 06.11.2022). (In Kazakh).

2. «Qazaqstan Respublikasynda memlekettık basqarudy damytudyñ 2030 jylğa deiıngı tūjyr ymdamasyn bekıtu turaly» Qazaqstan Respublikasy Prezidentınıñ 2021 jylğy 26 aqpandağy No. 522 Jarlyğy. URL: https://adilet.zan.kz/kaz/docs/U2100000522 (ötınış berılgen kün: 06.11.2022). (In Kazakh).

3. Karmys G.S., Bastaubaeva A.Zh. (2018) Procedura ob#javlenija konkursov o prieme na gossluzhbu Kazahstana v uslovijah cifrovizacii // Voprosy gosudarstvennogo i municipal'nogo upravlenija. No. 1. P. 140– 163. (In Russian).

4. Ryshkina Ja.Ju., Kulumbetova D.B. (2014) Problemy otbora i najma personala v Respublike Kazahstan // Vestnik Omskogo regional'nogo instituta. No. 1. P. 109–111. (In Russian).

5. Qazaqstan Respublikasynyñ Memlekettık qyzmet ısterı agenttıgınıñ 2020–2024 jyldarğa arn alğan strategialyq jospary. URL: https://www.gov.kz/memleket/entities/qyzmet/documents/details/63309?lang=kk (ötınış berılgen kün: 06.11.2022). (In Kazakh).

6. Qazaqstan Respublikasy Memlekettık qyzmet ısterı jäne sybailas jemqorlyqqa qarsy ısqimyl agenttıgı Törağasynyñ «Memlekettık äkımşılık lauazymğa ornalasudyñ keibır mäselelerı turaly» 2017 jylğy 21 aqpandağy No. 40 būiryğy. URL: https://adilet.zan.kz/kaz/docs/V1700014939 (ötınış berılgen kün: 06.11.2022). (In Kazakh).

7. Uitmor D. (2008) Kouching vysokoj jeffektivnosti. (In Russian).

8. Du Toit A. (2007) Making sense through coaching // Journal of Management development. (In English).

9. Chernyshova V.S., Lymareva O.A. (2017) Rol' kouchinga v sisteme najma personala // Simvol nauki. V. 1. No. 3. P. 149–151. (In Russian).

10. Vorob'jova M.A., Skurihina A. (2019) Tehnologija kouchinga pri otbore i nabore personala // Kognitivnye issledovanija v obrazovanii. P. 321–326. (In Russian).

11. Connors R., Smith T., Hickman C. (2004) Getting results through individual and organization accountability: The Oz principle. (In English).

12. Bobrova I. i dr. (2010) Problemy kouchinga // Novye rynki. No. 4. P. 10. (In Russian).

13. Sejtkaparov A.Zh. (2014) Kouching kak innovacionnyj instrument formirovanija motivacii personala sovremennyh kompanii // Molodoj uchenyj. No. 7. P. 409–412. (In Russian).

14. Husainov U. Sh. (2016) Nekotorye voprosy otbora kadrov na gosudarstvennuju sluzhbu // Pravo. Zhurnal Vysshej shkoly jekonomiki. No. 3. P. 139–147. (In Russian).

15. Nurbekova R.B., Ileuova G.T. (2022) Rekrutment v gosudarstvennom sektore Kazahstana // Vestnik universiteta «Turan». No. 2. P. 246–253. (In Russian).

16. Staronova K., Rybář M. (2021) Personal or party roots of civil service patronage? Ministerial change effects on the appointments of top civil servants // Administration & Society. V. 53. No. 5. P. 651–679. (In English).

17. Čehovin M., Haček M. (2015) Critical analysis of civil service politicization in Slovenia // World Political Science. V. 11. No. 1. P. 133–155. (In English).

18. Baimenov A., Liebert S. (2019) Governance in the post-Soviet era: Challenges and opportunities // Public Administration Review. V. 79. No. 2. P. 281–285. (In English).

19. Bertram I., Bouwman R., Tummers L. (2022) Socioeconomic Status and Public Sector Worker Stereotypes: Results from a Representative Survey // Public Administration Review. V. 82. No. 2. P. 237–255. (In English).

20. Staronova K. (2017) Civil-service reforms and communist legacy: The case of Slovakia // NISPAcee Journal of Public Administration and Policy. V. 10. No. 1. P. 177–199. (In English).

21. Liebert S. (2014) Challenges of reforming the civil service in the post-Soviet era: The case of Kyrgyzstan // Review of Public Personnel Administration. V. 34. No. 4. P. 403–420. (In English).

22. Gadowska K. (2018) Constitutional values and civil servant recruitment: The principles for filling revenue service positions in Poland // Communist and Post-Communist Studies. V. 51. No. 3. P. 257–271. (In English).

23. Nieto-Morales F., Ríos V. (2021) Human resource management as a tool to control corruption: Evidence from Mexican municipal governments // Public Administration. (In English).

24. Cooper C.A. (2022) Encouraging bureaucrats to report corruption: human resource management and whistleblowing //Asia Pacific Journal of Public Administration. V. 44. No. 2. P. 106–130. (In English).

25. Meyer-Sahling J., Mikkelsen K.S., Schuster C. (2021) Merit recruitment, tenure protections and public service motivation: Evidence from a conjoint experiment with 7,300 public servants in Latin America, Africa and Eastern Europe // Public Administration. V. 99. No. 4. P. 740–757. (In English).

26. Bright L. (2008) Does public service motivation really make a difference on the job satisfaction and turnover intentions of public employees? // The American review of public administration. V. 38. No. 2. P. 149– 166. (In English).

27. Nijazbaeva Ә., Kusherov N. (2021) Әlemdіk tәzhіribede ұrpaқtar teorijasynyң memlekettіk қyzmet zhәne biznes salasyndaғy қoldanysy // Memlekettіk basқaru zhәne memlekettіk қyzmet. No. 4, 4–15 b. (In Kazakh).

28. Esbergen R. (2022) Memlekettіk basқaru zhүjesіn bjurokratijadan aryltu tetіkterі. // Memlekettіk basқaru zhәne memlekettіk қyzmet. No. 3, 163–170 b. (In Kazakh).

29. Қazaқstan Respublikasy memlekettіk қyzmetі kadrlary zhajkүjіnің monitoringі. URL: https://www.gov.kz/memleket/entities/qyzmet/documents/details/283193?lang=kk (өtіnіsh berіlgen kүn: 06.11.2022). (In Kazakh). 30 Қazaқstan Respublikasynyң Azamattyқ kodeksi. Қazaқstan Respublikasynyң Kodeksі 1994 zhylғy

30. zheltoқsandaғy No. 268-HIII. URL: https://adilet.zan.kz/kaz/docs/K940001000_ (өtіnіsh berіlgen kүn: 06.11.2022). (In Kazakh).

31. 31 Қazaқstan Respublikasynyң Konstitucijasy. URL: https://adilet.zan.kz/kaz/docs/K950001000_ (өtіnіsh berіlgen kүn: 06.11.2022). (In Kazakh).

32. «Қazaқstan Respublikasyndaғy sajlau turaly» Қazaқstan Respublikasynyң 1995 zhylғy 28 қyrkүjektegі No. 2464 Konstitucijalyқ zaңy. URL: https://adilet.zan.kz/kaz/docs/Z950002464_ (өtіnіsh berіlgen kүn: 06.11.2022). (In Kazakh).